Version 2.0 Secure by Design Total Product Lifecycle

Measure the maturity of your product security program

A structured framework for assessing secure-by-design capability across the total product lifecycle. Score twenty-six security functions in six domains against five levels of maturity, evidence every score, and turn the gaps into a plan.

The scorecard runs entirely in your browser. No data leaves your machine.

Secure DesignSecure DevTestingRisk MgmtPrivacyLifecycle
Current maturity Target
6
Domains
26
Security functions
5
Maturity levels
130
Level descriptors

A common language for secure-by-design capability

The framework assesses the processes, standards and activities that support a product from concept and design through development, deployment, sustainment and end-of-life. It evaluates practices, not individual products — giving every division the same yardstick and the organisation a comparable view.

Find the gaps

Identify precisely where resources and attention are needed to strengthen security practice, function by function, rather than arguing from anecdote.

Measure improvement

Quantitatively track the effectiveness of improvement activities over time. Re-assess on a cadence and watch the profile move.

Plan and defend investment

A comprehensive view of organisational capability that supports informed decision-making, prioritisation, and strategic planning for secure-by-design initiatives.

Evidence for compliance

Higher maturity levels align with the expectations of regulators and industry standards, and the recorded evidence supports audits and submissions.

Comparable across divisions

One scale, one set of descriptors. Divisional self-assessments roll up into a portfolio view without translation.

Whole lifecycle, whole org

Scope reaches beyond engineering to any function that touches product security — data management, quality, service and support included.

The scale

Five levels of maturity

Each level represents a degree of formality and optimisation, from ad-hoc and reactive practice through to processes that are measured and continuously improved. Scores are recorded in half-steps, so a function part-way to the next level can be captured honestly.

1

Ad Hoc

Security capabilities and processes are either absent or inconsistently applied, leading to a lack of repeatability and reliability.

2

Basic

Basic security capabilities and processes are in place and can be repeated, but they lack formal definition and structure.

3

Defined

Security capabilities and processes are formally defined, documented, and communicated, ensuring consistency and enforceability.

4

Managed

Metrics and measurements are established to monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of security capabilities and processes.

5

Optimized

Security capabilities and processes are continuously improved through proactive monitoring, feedback, and automation.

The structure

Six domains, twenty-six functions

Every function carries its own definition and five written level descriptors. Open a domain to read them in full.

🔒

Secure Design

5 functions

Incorporating security principles and requirements into the design phase of product development, including threat modeling, architectural risk analysis, and security requirements.

Third-Party ComponentsSoftware Bill of Materials (SBOM)Security ArchitectureThreat ModelingCybersecurity Requirements
💻

Secure Development

4 functions

Implementing secure coding practices during the software development phase, including code reviews, secure coding standards, and integration of security tools.

Secure BuildSecure Coding & Code QualitySupply Chain Security & Manufacturing IntegritySecurity Training, Awareness & Culture
🧪

Security Testing

4 functions

Rigorous testing of products to identify and address security weaknesses through static and dynamic analysis, vulnerability assessment, and penetration testing.

Configuration Security & ValidationCybersecurity ControlsVulnerability Assessment & ManagementRed Team & Penetration Testing
⚠

Risk Management

4 functions

Systematic identification, assessment, and mitigation of security risks throughout the product lifecycle.

Measures & MetricsRisk Assessment & MitigationCybersecurity Governance & Program ManagementLabeling, Documentation & Compliance
🔐

Privacy & Data Protection

4 functions

Protection of personal and sensitive data through encryption, access controls, data anonymization, and compliance with privacy regulations.

Data Architecture & DesignData Inventory & ClassificationPrivacy & Data Security GovernanceSecure Data Processing & Handling
🔄

Lifecycle Management

5 functions

Maintaining and enhancing product security throughout its entire lifecycle, from development to decommissioning, including patch management and vulnerability disclosure.

Threat Monitoring & IntelligenceIncident Detection & ResponseProduct Lifecycle Transition ManagementCoordinated Vulnerability Disclosure & CollaborationPatch Management
The method

How an assessment runs

A division assessment is a facilitated, evidence-based conversation — not a questionnaire. The scorecard is built to support it end to end.

Scope and prepare

Agree the division, the products and the support functions in scope. Gather policies, standards, records and tooling evidence up front.

Score each function

Work through the twenty-six functions with the people who do the work. Award the highest level whose descriptor is consistently met, and record the evidence behind it.

Set targets, size the gap

Set a target maturity per function based on risk and regulatory exposure. The gap plan ranks what to fix first with owners and due dates.

Report and re-assess

Generate the report for leadership, export the JSON to keep the record, and re-assess on a cadence to show movement.

Scoring rule of thumb. A level is met when its descriptor holds consistently and demonstrably across the scope — not when it has been achieved once, on one product, by one team. When practice sits firmly between two levels, use the half-step.
The tool

The Division Maturity Scorecard

A single-file, offline assessment workbook for one division, one assessment. Everything the framework asks for, in a form you can hand to an assessor.

  • ✓Score all 26 functions against the written level descriptors, in half-steps, with current and target maturity.
  • ✓Capture evidence and recommendations per function, so every score can be defended later.
  • ✓Live scorecard and radar — domain profile, function scores and the gap to target, updating as you type.
  • ✓Gap plan ranked by size of gap, with owner, priority and target date.
  • ✓Printable report with executive summary, key findings and full domain detail — print to PDF straight from the browser.
  • ✓Autosaves locally, exports to JSON. Nothing is uploaded; re-import to continue or to compare assessments.
scorecard.html — Division Security Maturity Scorecard
Current2.6
Target3.8
Gap1.2
Scored26/26
Secure Design3.1
Secure Dev2.4
Testing3.8
Risk Mgmt2.8
Privacy2.0
Lifecycle3.5

Use it in your organisation

The framework and the scorecard are free to use and adapt with attribution. Fork the repository, adjust the domain and function set to your context, and host your own copy.

The canonical framework data — domains, functions and all 130 level descriptors — is published as framework.json so it can be pulled into your own tooling.

Citation

Hillyer, M. (2026). Product Security Capability and Maturity Framework: A framework for assessing the cybersecurity maturity of a secure product design program (Version 2.0).